Skip to main content
Blue Jackets
@
Islanders
NHL
Sunday, March 22, 2026

Blue Jackets @ Islanders

Columbus brings the hotter offense, stronger recent form and the better expected goalie into a two point Metro swing game.

PI
PicksOffice
·4 min read

Ad | Affiliate — I may earn a commission if you sign up through these links. This never influences my picks. Learn more

This matchup looks tight if you stop at the standings. It is not that simple once you look at how these teams are arriving here. Columbus is walking in on a heater. New York is trying to keep a one night blowup from turning into a real slide.

The number that sets the table

Columbus has won four straight and scored 18 goals in those four games. That matters because this is not a team sneaking out one goal wins. The Blue Jackets are creating enough offense to survive a messy second night and still push the game toward their style.

Recent form is not close right now

The Blue Jackets are 7-3 over their last 10 games. They have scored 39 goals and allowed 25 in that stretch, which works out to 3.90 scored and 2.50 allowed per game. The Islanders are 5-5 over their last 10, with 28 goals scored and 34 allowed, only 2.80 for and 3.40 against per game.

That split gets sharper when you cut it down to the last five. Columbus is 4-1 with 3.80 goals scored and 1.80 allowed per game. New York is 2-3 with 2.60 scored and 3.20 allowed. Same schedule spot today. Very different version of each team.

The season long scoring gap still points the same way

This is not only a hot streak case. Columbus is the better scoring team across the full season too. The Blue Jackets are at 3.22 goals per game, while the Islanders sit at 2.87.

That matters more on a back to back because the team with cleaner finishing usually handles the chaos better. Columbus has hit at least four goals in 7 of its last 10 games. New York has allowed at least three goals in 7 of its last 10 and in 3 of its last 5.

Expected goaltending gives Columbus the cleaner side

If the expected starters hold, Columbus should get Jet Greaves and New York should go with David Rittich. Greaves carries a .90872 save percentage with a 2.61246 goals against average across 44 appearances. Rittich is at .89766 with a 2.68754 goals against average in 27 games.

That is not a massive gap on paper, but it does matter in a one goal market. When the offenses are separated and both clubs are skating on tired legs, the goalie closer to a .910 profile is the safer side to trust.

Special teams and lineup shape favor the road side

Columbus owns a 20.35% power play this season. New York is down at 16.83%. If this game gets one or two key whistles late, that difference is enough to swing the result.

The Islanders also come in thinner than usual. Kyle Palmieri is on injured reserve after producing 18 points in 25 games, and Alexander Romanov remains out on the back end. New York can still defend structurally, but it is not the deepest version of this roster.

This is a real standings game, not filler

Columbus sits at 37-21-11 with 85 points. The Islanders are 39-26-5 with 83. That makes this more than another Sunday stop on the calendar. It is a direct Metropolitan swing game between teams separated by only two points.

Those are usually the spots where current form matters most. Columbus is bringing better recent offense, better recent defensive numbers, and the stronger expected goalie into a game where every point matters.

The counter case is easy to see

New York leads the season series 2-1 and owns a strong 18-11-2 home record. The Islanders also allow only 2.81 goals per game on the season, better than Columbus at 3.09 allowed. If you want to make the home favorite case, that is where it starts.

The problem is that the current version of New York is not cashing that profile. The Islanders just gave up 7 goals last night and have been outscored by 6 over the last 10 games. Columbus is moving in the opposite direction, with a four game win streak and a plus form gap that is too clean to ignore.

Decision

This comes down to which team is more likely to generate enough offense to win a tired game. Columbus has the better recent attack, the better season scoring rate, the better power play, and the better expected goalie. That is enough to side with the Blue Jackets even in a building where New York has usually been comfortable.

The Islanders can grind, but Columbus has more ways to get to three or four goals right now. In a two point race game, that is the side worth backing.

Stay Ahead of the Market

I share pick breakdowns, line value insights, and lessons from thousands of tracked bets. Straight to your inbox. No hype. No spam. Just the process.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy