Skip to main content
Giants
@
Dodgers
MLB
Tuesday, May 12, 2026

Giants @ Dodgers

Giants-Dodgers sits at 9, but recent totals, McDonald's command and Dodgers scoring form point lower.

PI
PicksOffice
·3 min read

Ad | Affiliate — I may earn a commission if you sign up through these links. This never influences my picks. Learn more

Giants-Dodgers can look dangerous on name power alone. The number is 9, though, and the recent run profile around this matchup has been much colder than the logos suggest.

The market already gave this game room

This is not a total that needs everything perfect. The listed total is 9.0 runs, which gives the bet a push lane if the game lands exactly where this series has already landed once in 2026.

The first three meetings finished with totals of 9, 5 and 5. Two stayed below the number and one landed directly on it.

San Francisco has been playing lower-scoring baseball

The Giants' last 10 games averaged 7.1 total runs. That is the first point in the handicap, because this is not a team dragging every game into double digits right now.

Seven of those 10 games stayed below 9. Two more landed exactly on 9, so only 1 of the last 10 cleared this number outright.

The Giants' recent scoring profile fits an under

San Francisco scored 41 runs across those last 10 games, good for 4.1 runs per game. That is enough to stay competitive, not enough to demand a bloated total.

The cleaner part is the prevention side. The Giants allowed only 30 runs across that same 10-game sample, a 3.0 runs allowed average that keeps this number from needing a dead offense to cash.

Trevor McDonald gives the bet a real starting point

McDonald is the best under piece in the game. In his first 2026 start, he worked 7 innings with 8 strikeouts, 0 walks and a 0.29 WHIP.

That is only 1 start, so the handicap should not pretend he is a finished ace. It still gives San Francisco a starter who has already shown he can carry clean innings without putting free runners on base.

Los Angeles has not been forcing shootouts

The Dodgers are 24-16, so the lineup respect is automatic. Recent scoring is less scary than the record.

Los Angeles scored 38 runs over its last 10 games, a 3.8 runs per game average. For a total sitting at 9, that recent output asks the Dodgers to break out or the Giants to do more than their current profile suggests.

The Roki Sasaki risk is priced into the number

Sasaki is the obvious reason this total is not lower. His 2026 line is 6 starts, a 5.97 ERA, a 1.67 WHIP, 15 walks and 8 home runs allowed.

That is not comfortable for an under. It is also why the number sits at 9 instead of a tighter total.

Weather does not carry the handicap

The listed weather is 71 degrees with 0 percent precipitation and wind 8 mph out. That is not a reason to force an under argument by itself.

The bet is about game shape. San Francisco has been keeping games down, McDonald gives the Giants a starter with strikeout control, and the first three meetings never cleared 9.

The decision

I took Under 9 because the number gives enough cushion for a rivalry game that has already produced totals of 9, 5 and 5 this season. The Giants' recent games are averaging 7.1 total runs, and Los Angeles is at 3.8 runs per game over its last 10.

Sasaki can make this messy. The price of that risk is already in the 9. If McDonald gives San Francisco anything close to his first-start command, this total is asking for more offense than the recent profile supports.

CHOOSE YOUR CHANNEL

Pick the feed that fits how you bet.

Telegram is fastest when you want the alert on your phone. Discord keeps the room, the recap, and the discussion in one place.

Telegram for speedDiscord for the full room